A Boxy Yellow Fish Shaped a Concept Car, Then Surprised the Scientists
Car engineers copied the yellow boxfish because it seemed sleek and steady, but a later study found the little cube of a fish is built for turning, not for keeping straight.
On a sunny coral reef in the Indian or Pacific Ocean, a small yellow fish with black polka dots drifts between the branches of coral, fluttering its little fins like a hummingbird. It is the yellow boxfish, Ostracion cubicus, and as its name suggests, its body is very nearly a cube. It does not look like anything an engineer would copy. In 2005, engineers did exactly that.
The fish behind the car
The boxfish wears its skeleton on the outside. A study in the Journal of the Royal Society Interface describes its carapace as a rigid armour of many hexagonal plates of bone, sewn together at the edges. Because the body cannot bend, the fish mostly swims by working its side, back and belly fins, and saves its tail for short bursts. In June 2005, DaimlerChrysler unveiled a concept car based on it, the Mercedes-Benz Bionic, at an innovation symposium in Washington. Its press release says engineers, designers and biologists worked on it together.
How the car borrowed from the fish
The engineers built a model of the fish and tested it in a wind tunnel, where it scored a remarkably low drag coefficient, a measure of how easily a shape slips through air. They then shaped a quarter-size clay car, and finally a working four-seat compact, 4.24 metres long, with a drag coefficient of 0.19 and a fuel use of 4.3 litres per 100 kilometres. The fish lent a second idea too. The release explains that the body was designed with a method based on how bone grows: material is added where loads are high and taken away where they are low, which it says cut the weight by around a third.
- 0.06 the boxfish model in the car maker's wind tunnel, 2005
- 0.19 the finished Bionic concept car
- 0.27 a yellow boxfish in a flow tank, 2015 study
What people often get wrong
The story usually told is that the boxfish is a natural self-steadying shape, sleek and stable, which is how the car's release described it: small swirls of water along its edges were said to keep the fish steady. The fish turned out to be the opposite. In 2015, a team including researchers from the University of Groningen measured boxfish bodies in a flow tank and ran computer simulations of the water around them. They found the shape does not steady the fish at all. The flow pushes it to swing and tilt, and the fish uses its tail fin as a rudder to keep a straight course.
How we know
The researchers tested two species, the cube-shaped yellow boxfish and a triangular relative, the smooth trunkfish. For the yellow boxfish they measured a drag coefficient of about 0.27, far higher than the earlier estimate the study quotes of below 0.13 for some species. Drag is measured in different ways by different teams, so the car maker's figure and the scientists' figure are not a fair head-to-head, and the sources do not agree on how slippery the fish really is.
What the study did conclude is that the wobble is useful. A fish that lives among coral needs to turn, tilt and squeeze through tight gaps, and a body that is easy to swing round is exactly right for that. So the boxfish gave engineers a fine car shape after all, just not for the reason they thought, and it carries on doing graceful little turns on the reef, unaware that it once inspired a car.
Sources
Where the facts in this piece come from. Each link leads to another website.
- Journal of the Royal Society Interface (PMC) — Boxfish swimming paradox resolved: forces by the flow of water around the body promote manoeuvrability (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
- University of Groningen — Has car manufacturer taken the corner too fast with the boxfish design? (rug.nl)
- Mongabay — Design of new Mercedes-Benz bionic car inspired by fish body shape (DaimlerChrysler release) (news.mongabay.com)
Found an error?
Tell us what is wrong and, if you can, where the correct information is published. We check every report, and when we fix an article we say so here and on the corrections page.