Why One Potato Mashes Into a Cloud and Another Keeps Its Shape
A floury potato falls apart into fluff while a waxy one stays firm in the pan, and the difference comes down to starch, water and the natural glue that holds its cells together.
On a winter evening in a small kitchen, two pots simmer side by side on the stove. In one, long brown potatoes are softening, their edges going rough and crumbly as they knock gently against each other in the water. In the other, small round red ones bob about looking almost exactly as they did when they went in, smooth and neat, as if somebody had asked them to behave. Both have had the same water and the same time, yet only one of them is ready to become mash.
A wall of tiny rooms
Inside, a potato is built like a wall of tiny rooms. Its flesh is millions of small cells stuck to one another, and each cell holds water and microscopic granules of starch. America's Test Kitchen, which has tested potatoes at length, counts more than 4,000 varieties in the world and names the amount of starch as one of the main things that decides how each one turns out once it is cooked.
The long brown potatoes in the first pot belong to the floury kind, like the russet, and they carry the most starch, at least a fifth of their weight. As they cook, their starch soaks up water, the cells swell, and they push one another apart, which gives the dry, fluffy inside that falls to pieces at the touch of a fork and drinks up butter and milk. The round red ones in the second pot are waxy. With less starch, their cells take in less water, and pectin released from the cell walls forms a gel that holds them together, so they stay dense and creamy.
- 20%+ russet, a floury potato that bakes dry and fluffy
- 16–18% Yukon Gold, somewhere in between
- ≈ 16% red potatoes, waxy and firm
How the cells come apart
Cooking does two things to a potato at once. A team of researchers led by Ormerod, writing in the Journal of Materials Science in 2002, described them as separate events that happen side by side: the starch inside the cells swells, and the binding between the cells weakens. That binding is the middle lamella, a thin natural glue between neighbouring cells. In their tests the cooked tissue lost much of its strength after 30 minutes at 80°C, or after only 5 minutes at 100°C.
What people often get wrong
It is easy to imagine the swelling starch bursting the cells open, like popcorn going off inside the potato. The research points another way. The same team worked with potato lines whose starch barely swelled at all, and those potatoes still weakened with heat in the same way as the others. Their cells were full of fluid instead of swollen starch, yet the tissue softened all the same, and the authors concluded that a potato goes soft mainly because the glue between its cells breaks down.
Cooks and scientists do not tell the story in quite the same words. Kitchen guides put the weight on swelling starch pushing the cells apart, while the 2002 study found the softening itself is mostly the work of the failing glue. Both agree on what reaches the plate: once cooked, a floury potato's cells come away from each other easily, and a waxy potato's cells stay snugly together. Mashing for too long spoils either kind, because it breaks the cell walls themselves, and the starch that spills out turns the mash gluey.
Back on the stove, the first pot is ready. The long brown potatoes slump apart under the masher into a soft, pale heap, each tiny room letting go of its neighbour without a fuss. The round red ones wait in the second pot, still neat and still whole, kept for a salad where holding their shape is exactly the point.
Sources
Where the facts in this piece come from. Each link leads to another website.
- Journal of Materials Science — Ormerod et al. (2002), The influence of starch swelling on the material properties of cooked potatoes (doi.org)
- America's Test Kitchen — The starchy secrets to cooking potatoes (americastestkitchen.com)
- RICARDO — How to make mashed potatoes properly (ricardocuisine.com)
Found an error?
Tell us what is wrong and, if you can, where the correct information is published. We check every report, and when we fix an article we say so here and on the corrections page.