Why Ice Cubes Have a Cloudy Middle, and How Bars Get Theirs Clear
Ice from a freezer tray hides a little white cloud at its heart, and it has less to do with dirty water than with air that runs out of places to go.
Pop a tray of ice out of the freezer on a summer afternoon and the cubes look lovely from the side: glassy at the edges, like little windows. Look closer and every one of them has a white, milky heart, a small cloud trapped in the middle as if someone had breathed into the water just before it froze. Drop one into a glass of lemonade and the cloud goes along for the ride.
The big crystal-clear blocks in a good cocktail bar seem to be made of a different substance altogether. They are made of the same water. The difference is not what went into the tray but the direction the cold came from, and the story of that small white cloud is a neat bit of physics hiding in the most ordinary corner of the kitchen.
What people often get wrong
The usual guess is that cloudy ice means the water was not clean, and the cloud is the minerals made visible. Minerals do play a part: Polly Burey, a professor of food science at the University of Southern Queensland, lists them among what gathers in the centre. But she also points out that even distilled water freezes from the outside in and still collects whatever is left in the middle. Better water alone, she writes, does not guarantee clear ice. The main culprit is something you cannot see in the glass at all: air.
How the cloud forms
Liquid water carries air dissolved in it, quietly, without a single bubble. Ice can hold some dissolved air too, but, as a Purdue University materials engineering page explains, in much smaller amounts. So whenever water turns to ice, the air that no longer fits has to go somewhere.
In a tray, the cold arrives from every side at once. The top, the bottom and the walls of each cube freeze first, building a shell of ice around a pocket of liquid. Each new layer pushes its spare air inwards, into the water that has not frozen yet. The pocket shrinks and the air in it gets more and more crowded. When the last drop in the middle finally freezes, there is nowhere left for the air to go, and it is locked in place as a crowd of tiny bubbles. Light hitting that crowded core is scattered instead of passing straight through, and the scattering is the white cloud you see.
How clear ice is made
The trick is to stop the cold arriving from every side. In directional freezing, the sides of a container are insulated so that the water freezes in one direction only, usually from the open top down. The ice then grows steadily one way, pushing the air ahead of it into liquid that is always there to take it, until the bubbles and impurities end up on the far side. Remove that last part and what is left is clear. Purdue describes clear ice in exactly these terms: water frozen from one end to the other.
What about boiling the water first? Here the sources do not quite agree. Indiana University's A Moment of Science programme recommends starting with hot water, because hot water holds less dissolved air and so makes fewer bubbles. Professor Burey agrees that boiling removes some of the gas, but says it does nothing to control how the ice freezes, so the cubes will still turn cloudy. The fair summary is that hot water may help a little, and the direction of freezing matters more.
So the cloud in your ice cube is not a flaw in the water. It is a record of how the cube was made: a tiny map of the last place the liquid held out, where all the escaping air finally ran out of room.
Sources
Where the facts in this piece come from. Each link leads to another website.
Found an error?
Tell us what is wrong and, if you can, where the correct information is published. We check every report, and when we fix an article we say so here and on the corrections page.