◴ Oddly .

Home Weird Facts

Old Church Windows Are Not Slowly Melting

Some medieval window panes really are thicker at the bottom, but the glass never trickled down over the centuries: the windows were made that way.

Sunlight pours through a tall stained-glass window of deep blue, ruby red and golden panes, casting soft patches of colour across the stone floor of an old church.

Step into an old cathedral on a sunny afternoon and the windows glow like a box of boiled sweets: deep blues, ruby reds and honey yellows, all held together by thin strips of lead. Look closely at the oldest panes and you may notice that they are wavy, with tiny bubbles trapped inside, and that some are a touch thicker at the bottom than at the top.

For generations, tour guides, websites and even some chemistry teachers have offered a neat explanation. Glass, they say, is really a liquid, just an extremely slow one, and over hundreds of years gravity has pulled it gently downwards, like honey creeping down the side of a jar. It is a lovely story. It is also wrong.

What people often get wrong

The melting-window idea mixes up two separate questions: what glass is, and why those particular panes are uneven. Glass is an odd material. Its atoms are jumbled, with none of the neat rows you find in a crystal of salt or sugar, so it looks a little like a liquid frozen in place. But scientists describe it as an amorphous solid. Mark Ediger, a chemistry professor at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, put it simply to Scientific American: if you grab it, it holds its shape.

Old glass also fails the test the myth sets for it. If glass slid downhill over centuries, far older glass should sag even more. Yet ancient Egyptian glass vessels show no such sagging, as Robert Brill, a researcher at the Corning Museum of Glass, has pointed out. And window glass at room temperature sits hundreds of degrees below the point at which it starts to soften.

Why the bottoms are thicker

The real answer lies in the workshop. According to teaching material from the University of Cambridge, medieval window glass was made by blowing molten glass into large cylinders, which were split open and flattened by hand. Nobody could make such sheets perfectly even, so every pane came out a little thicker in some places than in others. The people fitting the windows tended to put the heavier edge at the bottom, which is the steady, sensible way to stand a lopsided pane. Centuries later, visitors noticed the result and invented a story to fit it. Modern window glass, made by the float process, comes out flat and even.

How we know

Scientists have also done the sums. In 1998 the materials scientist Edgar Zanotto calculated, in the American Journal of Physics, how long cathedral glass would need to flow visibly at room temperature. In a follow-up with P. K. Gupta, the answer came out far longer than the age of the universe.

In 2018 a team led by John Mauro of Penn State went further, in a study in the Journal of the American Ceramic Society. They used the actual recipe of 13th-century glass from Westminster Abbey in London, and found that it flows far faster than the older sums suggested, by a factor of a one followed by sixteen zeros. Even so, Penn State notes, it would still take billions of years for the glass to change shape by a few nanometres, far too little for any eye to see.

So the next time you stand beneath a medieval window, enjoy the wobbles and bubbles for what they are: the fingerprints of glassmakers who worked by hand, long before anyone could make a perfectly flat pane. The window is not melting. It is simply showing how it was made.

Sources

Where the facts in this piece come from. Each link leads to another website.

  1. Penn State University — Researcher uses Westminster Abbey windows to shine light on glass myth (psu.edu)
  2. University of Cambridge, DoITPoMS — Do cathedral glasses flow? (doitpoms.ac.uk)
  3. Scientific American — Fact or Fiction?: Glass Is a (Supercooled) Liquid (scientificamerican.com)

Found an error?

Tell us what is wrong and, if you can, where the correct information is published. We check every report, and when we fix an article we say so here and on the corrections page.

Write to [email protected] · All corrections

Based on real facts. This piece describes real, documented facts and was written with the help of AI. AI can get details wrong, so check anything important with a trusted source, and tell us if you spot a mistake. More →

You might also like