Utah Has a Park Full of Stone Spires, and the Sculptor Is Ice
Bryce Canyon holds the largest crowd of stone spires in the world, and they were not carved by wind but by water freezing and thawing in their cracks, night after night.
In southern Utah, at the edge of a high plateau, a great many orange stone spires stand in rows. They are called hoodoos. Some are thin, some are lumpy, and many wear a paler, slightly wider slab on top, like a hat that does not quite fit. The National Park Service says Bryce Canyon National Park has the largest collection of them in the world. The spires have not commented.
What the spires are made of
They are made of old lake bed. The park traces the colourful rock to a lake that lay here about 50 million years ago, and lists what it became: limestones, dolostones, mudstones, siltstones and sandstones. The Utah Geological Survey names the layer that does most of the standing about. It is the pink member of the Claron Formation, and it is cracked from top to bottom. This matters.
How the ice does the carving
The park sits high. Its top point is 2,778 metres above sea level. The park counts more than 170 nights a year on which the temperature goes both above and below freezing; other accounts put the number of freeze and thaw cycles above 200. Either way, it is a lot of nights. The park calls what happens next ice wedging.
It works like this. Water runs into the cracks by day. At night it freezes. Water grows by about 9% when it turns to ice, so the ice pushes the crack a little wider. In the morning it melts and trickles a little deeper. Then the same thing happens on the next cold night, for a very long time.
Rain finishes the job. It is slightly acidic, which is enough to dissolve the calcium carbonate that holds the grains of rock together. Softer layers wear away faster than harder ones, so a spire narrows and bulges like a stack of plates from different sets. A tougher cap on top shields the softer rock beneath it. Hence the hat.
- 2,778 m the park's highest point above sea level
- 170+ nights a year that swing between freezing and thawing
- 9% how much water expands when it freezes
- 50 million years since the lake that left the rock
What people often get wrong
The obvious suspect is wind. It is a reasonable guess in a dry, open place. The park names two main forces instead, ice and rain, and wind is not on the list (it has not been informed). The second mistake is in the name. Bryce Canyon is not really one canyon. The park's geology survey describes its spires standing in a series of horseshoe-shaped amphitheaters along the edge of the plateau. The name stayed anyway.
The ice has not stopped. Every cold night still widens the cracks a little, so the spires are still being shaped, very slowly, in full view of everyone. The hats are staying on for now.
Sources
Where the facts in this piece come from. Each link leads to another website.
- National Park Service — Hoodoos, Bryce Canyon National Park (nps.gov)
- National Park Service — NPS Geodiversity Atlas, Bryce Canyon National Park (nps.gov)
- Utah Geological Survey — Picture of the day, Bryce Canyon National Park (geology.utah.gov)
Further reading
General background, not the evidence for the facts above. Each link leads to another website.
- Wikipedia — Hoodoo (geology) (en.wikipedia.org)
Found an error?
Tell us what is wrong and, if you can, where the correct information is published. We check every report, and when we fix an article we say so here and on the corrections page.